Crossword clues for the word: PINCHHITTER The word PINCHHITTER has appeared as an answer to at least 10 crossword clues on different crossword puzzles. Crossword clues for PINCHHITTER Showing 1 to 10 of 10 results Clue(s) Batty guy? Certain substitute player Late-inning substitute Nonstarter s role One coming off the bench One who'll go to bat for you? Player coming off the bench Substitute at the plate Substitute in an emergency Substitute who bats for a teammate: 2 wds.