Crossword clues for the word: OVERPAY The word OVERPAY has appeared as an answer to at least 12 crossword clues on different crossword puzzles. Crossword clues for OVERPAY Showing 1 to 12 of 12 results Clue(s) "Deserve credit, perhaps" "Give cash to a scalper, e.g." Be due a refund, perhaps Compensate in a way. Get a bad deal at the store Get gouged Get soaked Get soaked, say Give too much for. Give too much money Remunerate excessively You deserve credits when you do this