Crossword clues for the word: MAGGIEMAY The word MAGGIEMAY has appeared as an answer to at least 7 crossword clues on different crossword puzzles. Crossword clues for MAGGIEMAY Showing 1 to 7 of 7 results Clue(s) ... her favorite pop tune "Rod Stewart classic with the line ""You stole my heart but I love you anyway""" Rod Stewart hit Rod Stewart hit of 1971 Rod Stewart song Rod Stewart's first #1 hit Rod's first hit