Crossword clues for the word: COTTONMATHER The word COTTONMATHER has appeared as an answer to at least 8 crossword clues on different crossword puzzles. Crossword clues for COTTONMATHER Showing 1 to 8 of 8 results Clue(s) Increase's scion Infamous Puritan Influential 17th/18th-century theologian Puritanical preacher for the 2nd year Second-year colonial cleric Subject of Kenneth Silverman's 1985 biography U.S. clergyman-author: 1663-1728 Witch trials VIP